| 1 | Mitchell Whitmore (Neo) | USA | 35.57 | | - |
| 2 | Tucker Fredricks (Senior) | USA | 35.85 | | +0.280 |
| 3 | Trevor Marsicano (Senior) | USA | 36.60 | | +1.030 |
| 4 | Michael Blumel (Senior) | USA | 36.70 | | +1.130 |
| 5 | Matthew Plummer (Senior) | USA | 36.90 | | +1.330 |
| 6 | Matthew Rittenhouse (Neo) | USA | 37.08 | | +1.510 |
| Joey Mantia (Senior) | USA | 37.08 | | +1.510 |
| 8 | Andrew Astalos (A1) | USA | 37.44 | | +1.870 |
| 9 | Matthew Hickson (Senior) | USA | 37.48 | | +1.910 |
| 10 | Alexander Ochowicz (Senior) | USA | 37.83 | | +2.260 |
| 11 | Robert Brandt (M30) | FIN | 38.65 | | +3.080 |
| 12 | Nick Frank (Senior) | USA | 39.00 | | +3.430 |
| 13 | Anthony Sargent (Senior) | USA | 39.06 | | +3.490 |
| 14 | Chris Anderson (Neo) | USA | 40.02 | | +4.450 |
| 15 | Patrick Meek (Senior) | USA | 40.05 | | +4.480 |
| 16 | Theodore Aasen (Senior) | USA | 42.82 | | +7.250 |
| 17 | Robert Goodwin (A1) | USA | 43.65 | | +8.080 |
| 18 | Eric Castillo (B1) | USA | 46.19 | | +10.620 |
| 19 | Paul Montana (n/a) | USA | 47.89 | PB | +12.320 |
| 20 | Casey Dawson (D1) | USA | 54.91 | | +19.340 |
| 21 | William Valentine (D1) | USA | 57.98 | | +22.410 |